Quote:
Originally Posted by David Brown  That the tonality is different. But Roger, I don't think that's "meaningless", I think that's possibly significant. I wasn't talking about grain or sharpness, although since I mentioned those two aspects, I guess I misled ... They're too close there (in my experience) to be concerned about. (I'll edit my OP)
I understand that the answers I asked for will be subjective - it's why I asked. Objective comparisons can be looked up.  |
Dear David,
Fair enough. But how are you going to quantify or even describe this? "The tonality is different. I prefer this one." The test is meaningful in the sense that it might help you personally decide which you prefer, but it will help no-one else decide.
What I'm really questioning is the methodology: the usefulness of a head-to-head test, as compared with shooting real pictures with one, and the other, turn and turn about, and doing a rough statistical analysis of which gives you more pictures that you like.
Cheers,
Roger