PDA

View Full Version : Postcard Exchange Round 24 - Comments and Feedback



Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 [11] 12 13

piu58
01-18-2012, 11:37 PM
I received lacoat's photograph of a burger and fries restaurant too. Thank you very much! I was surprised to read that it was hard to get photos from negatives (instead of files).

Laurent
01-19-2012, 01:56 AM
I've got Labcoat's card also. Very nice one, showing a shop entrance. The framing inside the image (from the doors) makes it work fine. Thanks !

piu58
01-21-2012, 04:34 AM
Today I got a wonderful car form Roger R. Thoms. His double doors of en electric shop are fantastic.

Laurent
01-21-2012, 07:50 AM
Aron's N°20 arrived today. Square image of some derelict building and car, very moody. The paper has a slight warm tone, did you tone it or is it the normal aspect ?

Roger Thoms' card was also in the box, I love the framing (should I say the multiple frames in the image ?) of the doors, as well as the rendition of the perspective.

Thanks !

Aron
01-21-2012, 12:16 PM
Thanks for the comments. Laurent, the slight warm tone you see comes naturally from the warmtone paper + neutral (to slightly cold) working developer. I had only neutral tone developer at home when I tried this paper first, but I liked the reasult, so I sticked with it.

MattKing
01-23-2012, 08:11 PM
I’ve received three more fine cards:

ccross - “A Bunch of Dollars” - Fascinating patterns and a subtle print. I really like the “two card” packaging as well
labcoat - “Foliage in Colour” - I always appreciate cards in colour - surprisingly muted tones for Ektar 100
markrewald - “Alfalfa” - Great expression, and the print (borders and fogging included) go so well with it

20 down, 8 to go. EDIT: I've re-checked the count, and it appears that my counts have been off throughout. The correct number is actually 22 down and 6 to go.

Thanks to all for participating!

megzdad81
01-23-2012, 08:34 PM
Sign-up is over??

MattKing
01-23-2012, 09:00 PM
Sign-up is over??

For round 24, yes.

But round 25 is still open: http://www.apug.org/forums/forum179/99995-postcard-exchange-round-25-sign.html

Mike Wilde
01-25-2012, 11:54 AM
Labcoat – Maple in shade- on Ektar. A nice maple dominates the scene, and could almost have been a b&w shot heavy on the toning, so muted brown are the colour of the shadows. That is Ektar for you- a slide film like coating on a color negative film - great colour saturation, but little exposure latitude. So your shadows came out muted. The lit areas are nice and punchy. Lovely bits erupt where the sun pokes though the tree and breath patches of green. The figure included in the lower part of the scene gives an appreciated scale to the image. The black rebate adjacent the white border is a nice touch.

Markrewald – Alfalfa canted. The fogged edges are no issue for me. Gifted paper finds its way to me this way. Photo paper – oh it doesn’t fit my inkjet kind of people going through the estate contents of older relative who was an ‘olde schoole photo guy’.
There is a squarish part of the house that turns up in the background to the left of the dog’s head. I would have stood to see it held back a bit, to reduce the rectilinear image elements that otherwise fall into an image full of soft swirls and beautiful bokeh.
The very nice presentation of the shallow depth of field works very well. The eyes are most sharp, and the nose is acceptably sharp. The canto one side of the dog’s head is what makes it a great image to me.

Roger Thoms –Substation portal #5. The borders are most appropriately sized to the balance of the image and the cropping of the image into the frame is done most expertly. There are clean whites in the graffiti on one of the window panes of the door, and there is also good shadow detail in the door frames. Nice mid tones show us the modulation of light that the corrugated iron above the door produces. Very well done.

FotoGys
01-25-2012, 12:34 PM
I received Roger Thorms' double doors. Very nice shot, wel balanced and superb black & whites. I would like to see what's inside the building.

piu58
01-26-2012, 12:59 PM
Aron's Old factory near Budapest found its way to Germany. Thank you!
One thing postcard exchange is good for is seeing different types of paper. I love Fomatone MG classic very much.

Mike Wilde
01-26-2012, 01:11 PM
Craig Cross a Bunch of Sand Dollars arrived yesterday.

A very neat dark shellfish (actually I am not sure what a sand dollar actually is classified as) dominates the frame, over other more 'normal toned' shells.
Neat framing, good focussing. The print might have been presented a bit more effectively with more contrast.

The image is presented not square, but instead as slightly skewed to the paper edges. I am not sure if this was a paper mis-loaded in the easel issue, or an artistic statement that was intentional.
One small corner of the paper was also lightstruck. Again not sure if there is some deliberate design here, or just using up some slightly edge/corner fogged paper.

Black Dog
01-26-2012, 05:55 PM
I've sent most of mine out now:D and the rest will go 1st week of feb [happy year of the Dragon btw]

Roger Thoms
01-26-2012, 06:45 PM
Mike, thank for the comments on my card, glad you like it. As far as the borders there is a method to by madness. Half inch borders on 5x7 paper gives an image area of 4x6 which matchs the aspect ratio of a 35mm negative. I did end up with a slight crop to eliminate the edge of a window that didn't show up in my view finder.

I also wanted to thank Laurent and Fotogys for their comment as well.

Roger

tj01
01-27-2012, 06:26 AM
Received so far the following, safe and intact. Thank you guys for the beautiful cards.

1. Mike Wilde
2. James Dean
3. Jim Rollinger
4. Ryan Nerp
5. Jacco de Kraker
6. Rachelle Meilleur
7. Ashley Hoff
8. Darwin Poulos
9. George Richards
10. Nanette Reid
11. Laurent Barthélémy
12. Andrew Carson
13. Ricus Claassens
14. Matt King
15. Guus IJzereef
16. Mark Barendt
17. Marianne Pojman
18. Trond Båshus
19. Andres Palm
20. Mark Rewald
21. Johannes Markus
22. Romain Graciano
23. Andrew Vartabedian

Regards
TJ

piu58
01-28-2012, 08:25 AM
I got a card form Craig Cross whch showes an unusual sea urchin. very fine image, thank you!

Black Dog
01-28-2012, 04:58 PM
Likewise and thanks!

Ricus.stormfire
01-30-2012, 06:29 AM
Found a lovely portrait of Alfalfa in my box today, thanks Mark Rewald. The "effect" you got is quite awesome (now to figure out how to emulate it ;) )

Laurent
01-30-2012, 07:06 AM
I've got two cards :

Craig Cross's "Bunch of sea dollars". Lovely closeup (I've got a preference for the semi-glossy print over the glossy one).
Rory's Marin Headlands. wonderful print of a seascape, with a great tonal range (I usually do not really care for this range, unless it serves the print) which really make it shine. I first felt the foreground was blocked, but a closer look showed the grass' details. The feeling of light is very well conveyed, and the composition is close to perfection. (Note : I already thought I had to try ART300, and this print definitely confirms this !)

Thanks !

Tim Gray
01-30-2012, 02:23 PM
I got some really wonderful cards this round. Some of my favorite out of all the rounds I've participated in. My cards finally went out this morning. Sorry for being so late.