View Full Version : Postcard Exchange Round 24 - Comments and Feedback
02-03-2012, 12:52 AM
Yesterday I found Tim Gray's wonderful Hallgrímskirkja in my letter box. Thank you!
02-03-2012, 03:45 AM
I received Craig Cross's "A Bunch of Dollars. Like the composition very much, also a nice choosen presentation.
Also Tim Gray's picture of Hallgrimskirkja, like it a lot also because of it's basic less is more principle. Nice print to.
02-04-2012, 07:28 AM
I've also received cards from Roger Thoms, Johannes, ndrs, and ccross -- thanks to all!
Eagerly awaiting 8 more to finish the round...and if for some reason anyone has not received a card from me, please let me know. I have a few extras hanging around.
02-04-2012, 10:40 AM
An overdue update...
Three more cards received over the last few weeks:
Roger Thoms, "double doors", simple yet effective, well executed, I like it!
Aron, "no. 20", wow. Absolutely a great photo, lovely paper, all in all: a perfect picture. Without a doubt one of my favourites of this round so far.
ccross, "a bunch of dollars", great detail, an interesting view of this animal.
If anyone who should have received a card from me has not received it, or has received it in a bad state, please let me know. I still have a few spare cards, and it's not a problem to send one your way.
02-04-2012, 11:47 AM
I love Mark Rewalds friend Alfalfa, and the way his print turned out to be and I also received Wayne Frederick's man exiting a watertaxi, well shot moment.
Therefore I received the numbers 23 and 24 of 30. Wonderfull.
I also would like to know if anyone is still expecting a postcard from me. They could go missing in the post and I still have a few spares.
02-08-2012, 02:58 PM
Today I received Gordon's photo of Rose Deer Hotel. Thanks for this nice picture
02-08-2012, 05:51 PM
I also received Gord's Rosedeer Hotel. For some reason it seemed familiar to me and I now remember going out of my way to Wayne in my quest to photograph ghost towns across Canada. But for whatever reason I didn't take a picture of the hotel -- not run down enough perhaps? ;)
Also thanks to Tim Gray for his somewhat abstract shot of Hallgrimskirkja and to Wayne Frederick for his Water Taxi shot. In both pictures I like the shifting tonal values that draw my eye all over the image.
02-11-2012, 06:25 AM
This week I've got :
GordRob's Rose Deer Hotel. Interesting building, looks like the ones I'd see in Western movies...
Wayne Frederick's man exiting a watertaxi. I like the general mood, and the poles add a symetry to the composition which I like.
Mark Rewald's Alfalfa. I too like the "fogged paper" effect, as well as the composition and eye contact...
Tim Gray's Hallgrimskirja. Very interesting rythm in this composition !
02-11-2012, 10:50 PM
Well, seems I got quite a few cards whilst I was on holiday in AU! I received the following over the past couple of months:
Andrew's "View of South Park from Boreas Pass" - love the detail in this image, makes me yearn even more for a 5x4.
Gord's "Rose Deer Hotel" - If I ever get the chance to visit Canada, think this will be one place I'd love to visit and shoot myself.
Tim's "Wall" in Reykjavik - Nice texture in those concrete posts.
Andres' "Gang" - kids always love to play at this
Aron's "No 20" - love this paper!
Mark Rewald's "Alfalfa" - Mark, the paper fogging(?) doesn't worry me either - she's a real cutie!
Roger's "Double Doors" - Great contrast in the print; matches the subject really well!
Craig's "A Bunch of Dollars" - I've never heard of these called that before! And to think I must have been a millionaire as a kid. . . . . . .
02-12-2012, 03:30 PM
Three more cards arrived last week:
markrewald, Alfalfa. Been looking at this card the whole week. Whatever happened to that paper is amazing, it looks absolutely great with this subject.
Tim Gray, upon first seeing this card, I loved the minimalistic approach. Beautiful shades of grey, nicely changing from pillar to pillar. Then I read the back. Nothing 100% certain yet, but the plans are to visit Iceland this summer. I've seen the church in the books and guides, but wouldn't have recognised it on your photo. You've truly managed to give us a different view on a famous landmark. Now I really want to go there!
gordrob, Rose Deer Hotel (or is it Rosedeer-hotel?), captured on a sunny and windy day, by the looks of it. Personally I might have tried printing this with just a bit more contrast. Nice capture, the wheels, the railroad track (still used, or not?), the typical buildings.
Thanks. If I'm not mistaken, I've received 22 out of 25 cards so far, which I consider a very good score!
02-13-2012, 11:01 AM
Today I found Jake Wiliams' "A moment..." in my letterbox. It reminds me my own children when they werey younger. Now the are 25 and 23.
Thank you for your comments. The PC Exchange is always a good opportunity to see what images work better, what less so.
I've received these four cards since I last commented:
Roger R. Thoms: Lovely subject, with a great nested composition and beautiful tonality.
Labcoat: "Burger Delite", a great colour card with a classic theme.
Wayne Frederick: Nicely captured moment (especially knowing it was taken with a 4x5 camera) and the gentle tones which I primarily contribute to the uncoated lens (and good use of materials) are just lovely.
Tim Gray: Wow. OK, I admit I'm biased since I have a sweet spot for such well composed, minimalistic images like this one. One of my favourites for this great round.
02-13-2012, 02:22 PM
Sorry for being so late with my comments for this round. Lots of great cards received (in no particular order):
BlackDog: Beautifully printed and very poetic!
markrewald: I don't mind the fogged paper effect either. Looks like a friendly dog!
ccross: A good abstract.
kc2edh: A very successful attempt at infrared, and a beautiful landscape.
andrew.vartabedian: A grand landscape in a small format. Interesting combination.
gordrob: "Rose Deer Hotel". Interesting building. Would love to visit that hotel some time.
hoffy: Love this one! Several layers of framing, and very well printed.
Aron: Another lovely print. Just beautiful!
kraker: This photo made me read more about Doel. Seems absurd that one can demolish an entire village.
Laurent: Great photo of an artist at work!
ozphoto: Fantastic sports photo. Had to look up Australian Rules Football too.
ndrs: These two would scare me if I met them!
Rom: I wish I had this view on my way to work!
Roger Thoms: I like doors. Nice photo of an interesting sample.
labcoat: Color photo! The diner looks a little scary for some reason.
Tim Gray: A different, and very successful, view of this famous building.
Wayne Frederick: Looks cold and windy!
02-13-2012, 02:39 PM
Today, Jake Williams' photo I found on the doormat. Love the portret and composition, maybe a little to hard in print imo, but as Uwe stated reminds us of earlier days.
The statement on the back "everything around you, in the eyes of a sensitive photographer, can offer endless possibilities and chances to see where theytake you" I would say is well spoken and so thru.
02-20-2012, 01:50 AM
I have been a little poor on timely responses to the cards I have rec'd since the middle of Jan or thereabouts.
7 more cards in - 25in, 5 to go.
I no particular order I have
gordrob - Rose Deer Hotel. To someone from down under this looks just like what I would expect to see in old western movies. I take it where this hotel is situated the coal dried up and the town died a slow death?
Tim Gray - Wall of Hallgrimskirkja. Another image of great symatry and the light columns in the centre that grow darker toward the edges of the picture.
Craig Ross - A bunch of Dollars. Took me a while to work out what you had photographed, but when I did it was obvious. The close detail was what threw me initially.
Roger R. Thoms - Double Doors. Well framed. The rectangular doors forming a square, then framed by more rectangles. Great image that has drawn many comments from the visitors to my home.
labcoat - Burger Delite. Great to get another colour picture and with hand written notes as well. Thank you.
ndrs - Gang. If my kids tried dressing up like this they and I would be ordered to seek councilling:). But it is not to unlike what I would have been up to when I was 10 just 30 years ago.
Mark Rewald - Alfalfa. I love the effect that you achieved with the print.
02-22-2012, 03:48 AM
Jake's card arrived today - a nice study of childhood innocence.
Only 2 outstanding from this round.
02-23-2012, 08:46 AM
Jake's Moment gathered fro coincidence. Looks like a mom showing a son how to wrap a.. valentines gift? with a ribbon and how to tie it. Nice backlighting on the mom and child from ambient lighting spilling in the kitchen window.
Reminds me of all the things I learned from my Mom at the kitchen table or kitchen counter. Nice image.
02-23-2012, 12:15 PM
Today Rai's pinhole photograph 'OPEN AND CLOSED' arrived. It has taken some time but is definitly worthwile waiting for. I really love this picture, very moody, fascinating composition and beautifull print, a picture to watch over and over.
02-26-2012, 12:01 AM
I’ve received four more fine cards:
Roger Thoms - "Double Doors" - Interesting patterns and textures, and really well printed too
gordrob - "Rose Deer Hotel" - Always like a good "Last Chance Saloon" :) - nice use of the Cooltone Developer
Tim Gray - "Hallgrimskirkja" - A striking, perspective challenging abstract
Black Dog - "A Moment Gathered from Coincidence" - A wonderful connection - is it father and son?
26 down, two (hpulley and RHITMrB) to come.
Thanks to all for participating!
02-29-2012, 05:33 AM
Jake Williams' (Black Dog) postcard arrived today, very nice square portrait. Thank you