Hardening fixer

[MartinCrabtree]

Are there any modern 35MM B&W films that require a hardening fixer? Just curious.

[Ian Grant]

Some might prefer to use one with EFKE/Adox films but I've happily used Hypam with these films over the past few years.

So there's no simple answer if you take care with temperatures softer emulsions are ok with non hardening fixers. For me there's no film that requires one.

Ian

[Sundowner]

I don't know of anything that I've seen that "requires" one...but hardening fixer is pretty much "required" by me, personally, since I tend to scratch everything I touch.

[MartinCrabtree]

Ahhh......................thanks Sundowner. That's a good point for a neophyte like me. Never would have thought of that on my own.

[Vaughn]

I have had hardener ruin negs when developing 8x10 film in a 3005 Jobo Expert Drum -- there would be a permanent mineral-like deposit on the back side of the films.

[MattKing]

I'd encourage someone more in the know than me to jump in on this, but my understanding is that 35mm film from Kodak, Ilford or Fuji (and most others) is pre-hardened, and as a result adding hardener at the fixing stage does not improve their ability to resist physical damage - it just makes them harder to wash.

[Rhodes]

Ilford hypam is a hardening fixer? I ask because is my current fixer, but thought that was similar to ilford rapid fixer. a non-hardener, right?

[jnanian]

i do work for federal and state archives
and they require NON hardened fixer
because hardener tends to trap in
stuff you want to wash out
if you attempt to do
archival-anything

good luck !
john

[MattKing]

Ilford hypam is a hardening fixer? I ask because is my current fixer, but thought that was similar to ilford rapid fixer. a non-hardener, right?

I think Ian is referring to Hypam as a non-hardening fixer, which I understand to be correct.

Its main difference from Ilford Rapid Fixer is that it will permit the adding of hardener, if one has a special purpose process that requires hardener.

[Sundowner]

because hardener tends to trap in stuff you want to wash out

I did not know that...hmm...

I also had not heard of pre-hardened films in 35mm.