Grain as much as possible ...
Hi all again!!!
How can I get as much as grain as possible? Some special combination film/developer/time/temp/agitation?
Thank you very much,
Try Delta 3200, expose at box speed, develop in Rodinal and over-agitate. See how you like it!
Others may have gotten good grain with pushing Tri-X too.
anything in Rodinal 1+25 at high-ish temperature.
one good way is to use paper developer like dektol 1+3 or d-72 1+1 or multigrade 1+3, temperature 22ºc and around 5 minutes for tmz @1600, you won´t get reasonable shadow detail so increasing contrast on the printing stage can help to make the grain look more visible and sharper, contrast will be a bit on the high side, but you have to deal with these things.
another way is to use the only developer formulated especifically to do this: FX-16 by Geoffrey Crawley
it takes glicyn, so i did not use it often, it goes bad relativelly fast, but the results are better, less mushyness and more aparent sculptoric quality, it is a FX-2 derivation.
another good way is to enlarge..., use a fast film with good old rodinal and instead os using a normal lens use a wide angle and enlarge in the enlarger the smaller portion in the neg., it´s the easyest way... but you also lose some resolution
cumprimentos de portugal
Add good for standard BW printing. If you really want grain, learn to lith print and use Slavich or the insanely grainly Fomabrom VC (Arista.edu). I just posted a Slavich example. There are a bunch in the galleries and flickr
Sponsored Ad. (Subscribers to APUG have the option to remove this ad.)
one of the best ways to get grain
is to use a wider lens than you would normally use
in any situation, and enlarge ( i use a half frame and 110 camera for this).
you could also shoot at a higher iso and process accordingly.
there are people that suggest processing your film in dektol or other print developers
will give "huge golfball type grain" this has never been my experience
( i have been processing my film in a print developer for 11 years )
Before, it was easy...
Fuji Neopan 1600 @ 1600 in Rodinal 1+25 or 1+50.
Now that Neopan 1600 is gone, Tri-X @ 1600 in Rodinal 1+25.
I think also increasing the wet time of your film can also increase the grain.
Like John I've processed film in Ansco 130, and it doesn't give grain any bigger than with say Rodinal or HC-110.
The suggestion of cropping is great, but limits how big you can make the pictures in your enlarger.
The suggestion of using Delta 3200 or TMax 3200 is good too, especially if you process in something like Rodinal 1+25, shoot at 3200 and agitate a lot when you process. It yields a beautiful negative that prints with glorious grain.
Or like Mark Fisher suggests, to lith print yields some interesting results too. Two lith prints from a grain free and ultra smooth medium format pinhole negative attached to show the effect. This gives you the option to both have super grainy prints and smooth ones too, if you wish.
"Make good art!"
- Neil Gaiman
"...the heart and mind are the true lens of the camera".
- Yousuf Karsh
"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit".
Originally Posted by Thomas Bertilsson
that looks good for me, specialy the second image. That's what I'm looking for!!! But, how did you get it? Ok, lith printing (I know what is it) but which developer? Which film? Which paper (lith) developer? ...
Thanks to everybody for your help,