Most schools are still using film to teach kids basic photography 101 as well as offering digital courses later.
Anyone can make a Digital print, but only a photographer can make a photograph.
Saint Paul,on the road to Damascus
'Give me chastity,Lord,but not yet'.
There,another Shibboleth ignored..
Surely,any path to imaging which includes silver-halide is,or deserves to have,a place in these discussions ?
No offence intended,but DPUG is almost moribund - cannot we tolerate a little 'evil imaging' talk without the huffing and puffing ?
B.Carnie has some good points to make - I have started a custom B&W process service,and I know,from the feedback I get,that my customers are intending to sc*n their film -folks who don't have the time, or perhaps the space,but still want the unique qualities that film provides.
As far as I am concerned,they are FILM users -what part of that is unacceptable here?
A small hybrid forum with an emphasis on the workflow (no computer and not too much photoshop talk) would be a good addition to Apug imho.
People complaining on APUG about people wanting to know how to best scan their negatives are a little hypocritical since most of them scan their negatives in order to be able to show them to other Apug users. Criticizing people too much for asking how to best scan negatives might drive them to using Evil Cameras and completely abandon the analogue world.
Yes , but the more new people demanding the products we use will make it better for those of us on APUG who need the paper, is a great start.
The schools need to see the reasons for at least keeping a sink line and exposing unit operating.
I am just interested in the ability of talking about hybrid on APUG, one of the homes of darkroom printers.
Originally Posted by jglass
Really? Our local college, which has an active arts program, dumped the darkroom from their photgraphy courses about 3 years ago. I bought a whack of 16x20 paper on sale when they closed down, but now there's no where in this small city to buy darkroom supplies.
Originally Posted by paul ron
Anything that keeps interest up in film and paper is good for all of us. I agree that DPUG doesn't really work. I know there was a hybrid sub-forum here, before I joined. I would have no objection to it returning. It can always be ignored by the purists. Personally I much prefer an all-analogue workflow, but I've used diginegs, and I've scanned and printed on inkjet. I'm sure there'll be reasons to do so again.
Apug's my 1st choice when I'm looking for photography information, or when I'm just surfing around putting in a few minutes on down-time.
Sponsored Ad. (Subscribers to APUG have the option to remove this ad.)
I'd like to add my "one bit" for a hybrid forum for all the reasons cited here. To return to Bob Carnie's original question, I'm interested to hear how Foma 532-II compares with 131/132 and 111/112 in terms of tint, development time (generally, comparatively) and ease of use. Great discussion here - thanks all.
I too agree that analog photography, as a whole, would be better off if we allowed hybrid work flow discussion into a dedicated segment of the forums.
Has anybody pitched this idea to Sean Ross? And what is the response? Or do we need to do something about that?
"Make good art!"
- Neil Gaiman
"...the heart and mind are the true lens of the camera".
- Yousuf Karsh
"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit".
Anyone printing in analog should have a place at out family table. What better way to pull people into the light of analog? I tried to follow the digi-neg discussions on DPUG, but lost interest when I saw so few people there.
Isn't there some dispensation for groups? I recall people wanting to discuss cine film, where it is unavoidable to discuss telecine, Final Cut etc these days. They were told it was OK within a group & a cine group was started. Not sure how successful it was, but that would be irrelevant to the current discussion. I suppose my big fear is the general forum being taken over by people who want to argue about the difference between a 5D and a D3 - the mindless digi tech trivia seen on so many photo forums these days. Perhaps you can start a hybrid print group, get some keen interested members & share the knowledge you want there. It might get you where you want to be, rather than getting bogged down in a "Should APUG change?" debate.
I'm talking about the groups that operate within APUG, but you have to be a member to read them.