Lee compendium hood not suitable for 4x5?

[butterfly]

Folks, advice please..

I wanted to buy a Lee hood for my 4x5. The widest lens I use is a 90mm f4.5 rodenstock grandagon. I e-mailed Robert white uk to ask if the standard or wide-angle version would be most suitable. This is the reply:

'It is our opinion that the Lee hood will result in vignetting issues and not even the wide angle will be good enough'.

I often bow to their superior knowledge but cannot believe Lee hoods are not suitable for my needs!

Comments appreciated.

Steve

[David A. Goldfarb]

I think that reply is more about the lens than the hood. A 90/4.5 Grandagon is probably wide enough that the adapter for a Lee system could vignette even before you attach the hood if you need the maximum image circle, but you may still have plenty of image circle to work with on 4x5". You would have to test it to find out whether it will be a problem for you.

[Sean McEntee]

I have a Lee Hood and with my Schneider SA 90mm I get vignetting with the mounting ring, before the hood is even attached. Sorry I can't say for the Rodenstock, but you could compare image circles. I some times use blackwrap (cinefoil) to make a shade in the field.

[David A. Goldfarb]

B+W makes a nice screw-in rubber wide angle hood.

[butterfly]

Thanks for the replies. I saw a B+W wide angle metal hood. £50 !! Apparently they are hand made and stamped with the individual makers name ! But if it does the job..

[fschifano]

http://www.camerafilters.com/pages/lenshoods.aspx

They are inexpensive. Buy a few different ones. I use 'em. They work as well as any other lens hood.

[Martin Aislabie]

I don't bother with a lens hood - I just flag with the dark slide

It has the added advantage that I know I have the darkslide out when I trigger the shutter (I think we have all done that one)

A LF Lens Hood needs to be so wide to take into account movements - that is has virtually no value

Martin

[colrehogan]

Lee makes a wide angle adapter which should be fine. I have one (a wide angle adapter) for my 90 mm Nikkor-SW lens, but haven't used 4x5 in a while. I'm pretty sure I've used it before with no vignetting problems.

[fschifano]

I don't bother with a lens hood - I just flag with the dark slide

It has the added advantage that I know I have the darkslide out when I trigger the shutter (I think we have all done that one)

A LF Lens Hood needs to be so wide to take into account movements - that is has virtually no value

Martin

using the darkslide as a shade is the simplest method and with a little care can work as well as and other shade. But the rest of your argument doesn't hold water. A screw on lens hood is attached to the lens and moves with it when you make adjustments to the standard. A compendium type lens shade is attached to the front standard and moves when you make adjustments to the standard. If there is no interference (vignetting) with the standard centered, how can it be a problem when shifted if the whole setup moves as a unit? Adjustments to the back of the camera can be troublesome in either case.

[Martin Aislabie]

Frank, you are effectively looking out through a different areas of the lens to get movements

Hence the lens hood has to be set to a wide angle than the angle of view of the lens

If you have a few minutes try it for yourself

Martin