|
|
|
-
Plagiarising Ryuji Suzuki?
I googled Konica SD-28 and found a web page entitled "Seventy-six years of D-76". It appears to be an exact copy of an article I remember reading some years ago on Ryuji Suzuki's silvergrain website. The copy is found at http://jeffreysoper.com/node/101. I cannot find the article on Ryuji's site any longer....
As far as I can tell, the copy does not give attibutibution or cite Suzuki anywhere.
It looks like blatant plagiarism to me but, maybe...????
-
All of this goes back to original sources quoted in his references. He even quotes references to references such as A&T referring back to Haist. Haist and Dundon did much of the prior reporting on this and that is why all of it sounds so similar.
PE
-
 Originally Posted by BradS
I googled Konica SD-28 and found a web page entitled "Seventy-six years of D-76". It appears to be an exact copy of an article I remember reading some years ago on Ryuji Suzuki's silvergrain website. The copy is found at http://jeffreysoper.com/node/101. I cannot find the article on Ryuji's site any longer....
As far as I can tell, the copy does not give attibutibution or cite Suzuki anywhere.
It looks like blatant plagiarism to me but, maybe...????
As the formatting is the same . . . . well spotted. He does mentiont the source though on the next page "The D-76 family of developers was based on an article "Seventy-six years of D-76" published by Ryuji Suzuki (http://silvergrain.org/Photo-Tech/d-76.html)"
Ian
Last edited by Ian Grant; 01-15-2012 at 02:39 PM. Click to view previous post history.
-
Isn't this RS's problem? Maybe he gave permission, maybe not, but why not ask him before posting something like this?
-
[QUOTE=BradS;1286349]I googled Konica SD-28 and found a web page entitled "Seventy-six years of D-76". It appears to be an exact copy of an article I remember reading some years ago on Ryuji Suzuki's silvergrain website. The copy is found at http://jeffreysoper.com/node/101. I cannot find the article on Ryuji's site any longer....
As far as I can tell, the copy does not give attibutibution or cite Suzuki anywhere.
It looks like blatant plagiarism to me but, maybe...????[/QUOT
He's obviously aware of Suzuki's work and cites it here(http://jeffreysoper.com/node/105)but the link's dead.
Think he's just lazy/sloppy rather than deceitful.
Call him into your office?
-
Sponsored Ad. (Subscribers to APUG have the option to remove this ad.)
-
Why not ask Ryuji. He is active on APUG. I recall that quite a while back his web-server - provider - whatever, either crashed or shut down operation and a lot of his online information was lost. I believe he made a request on the alt-photo-process-list to see if anyone had some downloaded material to help restore the site. I forget the details, but as I said, just shoot him an email or pm.
Hope this helps.
Cheers,
Clarence
-
At the bottom, the page says it was written in 2003.
PE
-
Ha, that article is mine. Unless I specifically include express terms of license, people should respect the U.S. copyright laws and general protocol to obtain permission...
For record, I never released anything as "public domain" meaning you can do whatever you want kind of deal.
I released some material on the web with a type of Creative Commons license that requires proper attribute and allows no derivative work or commercial use.
When asked, I'm generally generous about non-commercial reprint permission. I am usually happy to participate in interviews, lectures or contribute articles. But stealing article without identifying the original author isn't cool...
|
|
Adv Reply
