Estelle Justim has said that Adams was a 19th Century artist who used 20th Century materials whereas Weston was just the reverse.
Originally Posted by Bob F.
I'm not denigrating him. I'm just stating the facts, ma'am. Most of Adams' work is the most carefully crafted illustration work ever done. Some of it is a modernist aesthetic, but not much of it. The Group f/64 Manifesto notwisthanding, most of Adams' work is about the subject of the photograph, Clearing Winter Storm being a good case in point. It's about clouds over Yosemite Valley, not about form and spatial relationships.
BTW, if you ever get a chance to see those Parmalian prints in person, don't pass it up. They're breathtaking.
I completely agree with you Jim.....and a very good Weston observation. If I had the computer skills I would display the Clearing winter storm Adams) side by side with Carlton's Entrance to Yosemite....
Now, If given a choice to own only one print in my personal collection and had to choose from Weston or Adams... not both, I personally would choose Weston's Pepper 1930.
I would also however, like a Carlton Watkins or another of the early pioneer photographers who so laboriously documented Yosemite and the west in the 1860's-1880's.
No one ever seems to mention Adams interrment documentary photographs?
Dave in Vegas
Parmelian prints....yes Adams in later years pointed to 2 of them as a turning point in his career "artistic breaktrough" Monolith, and the Face of the Half Dome, - although 2 dimensional-planar-paper used then produced a flattened quality...refer to article mentioned above...
it was Weston who inspired "straight photography" razor sharp focus...lens close to subject....abstracted component parts...full tonal range...
one more note....early in Weston's career....look to 1920 Nude...example on page 148 "Great Photographers" revised edition Time Life books....
1. Submerged detail
2. Soft focus-very diffused
3. but emphasis on shape and shadow
which were the parks? I'm not aware of the history of some of the other parks, but the process for Yosemite to be "set aside" for the nation was started by Lincoln in part as a result of Muybridge and Watkins photographs. A but before Adams' time (even if he did use their tripod holes)
Originally Posted by rhphoto
Along with Muir
Sponsored Ad. (Subscribers to APUG have the option to remove this ad.)