HCB and Winogrand
Good thread, insightful comments regarding both mens' work. For me it's like comparing Joe Dimaggio to Willie Mays. Each made plays that will stay forever in the memory, and if you're an aspiring baseball player there is much to be learned from both. One thing's for sure, both Joe and Willie knew the decisive moment to swing the bat! So I think the same can be said for photography: you can capture the decisive moment whether you use a Leica, Linhof, Holga, or Pinhole -- even digital!
I have tried to look at every published example of both Winogrand's and Cartier-Bresson's work. And I've gone back and studied the work over and over for years - I think it's important to do that, to let it sink in and internalize it. I've also tried to read all the criticism available on both men, as that can also teach you a lot.
Hopefully a little of their work rubbed off, as I tried to apply what I learned in my book, which you can see some samples of here .
Isn't the "Kiss in front of ....?" a decisive moment shot in spite it was posed ?
I mean The kissers are posing but as I recall people are passing by in the image.
No Mike, not really . I general you should go the other way round. First study their work and get your own opinion and then discuss it with others if you like to do so.
Originally Posted by Mike Lopez
What is written or said about photogs is not relevant in this context, their photos are relevant soley.
A la recherche du temps perdu: www. bersac.de
From a practical standpoint you will find yourself spending a great deal of money in getting some shots that you find pleasing and you will find yourself missing photos that could have easily been sucessfully taken with a 35mm.
I wish you good luck but I think that you will be bashing your photographic head against the wall of reality in the choice of equipment for the type of work you wish to do.
Claire (Ms Anne Thrope is in the darkroom)
Cartier Bresson vs. Winogrand?
Cartier Bresson by armbar in the first round.
Sponsored Ad. (Subscribers to APUG have the option to remove this ad.)
Of course the title of the book The Decisive Moment was originally Images a la Sauvette - which means something rather different. Hard to translate but maybe 'images on the fly' or 'fleeting moments' or possibly even 'very quick on the eye'.
"L'Instant décisif" was only one smaller part of the book, but was chosen by the the publishers of the English edition as the snappier title. But it does rather alter the overall emphasis.
The photography of HCB is truely magnificent. The decisive moment can be predicted, and plannen if one has time. You find an interesting venue, you set up shop, get exposure details etc. and wait until what you think will happen happens, and surely it will most of the time, and because of your stanionary character you will be able to adjust to lightning conditions and range all of the time, this in order to get the right shot at the right time.
Think of HCB "man jumping over puddle shot" many people think it was composed, well it was composed in such a way that HCB was ready for it, and could shoot at the point required ....
Many good street shots are done that way, all you need is time and patience, and to try and find a stationary spot. It might take a number of days to get the shot you want, but that will be all part of the fun...
... forgot ... and then one can use huge monorails if one wishes, no specific need for rangefinders/35mm.
I think this statement is true.
Originally Posted by Jorge
However with my Littman they aren't any more difficult to make than with a 35mm. There are some differences obviously. No zoom, no 36 exposures, no concealing it under your trench coat, but then a 35mm is still a very small negative.
I'd think with a Littman or a Crown Graphic a person could easily master the large format much the same way people like WeeGee did.
I couldn't think of anything witty to say so I left this blank.
Sadly,one is rarely free these days to smoke Weegee-style cigars.
You also need a big honkin flash, which makes Weegee rather unlike either HCB or Winogrand (tho Garry used flash sometimes, as in "Stock Photos" ot "Public Relations")
The question "what are you trying to acheive?" does come to mind.