Originally Posted by Andy K
The blind exchange is only one print, the group exchanges are usually 3 or 4 prints. I usually send a 10x8 in a stiff cardboard envelope made for photos and if you send them "printed papers" rate it's not too bad, usually about £1.30 - £1.70 to USA or Oz. Yes, the postcard exchange has increased greatly this round -- it's currently up to 35 and I've just spent 15 quid on stamps this morning. But it's great fun and my favourite exchange.
Originally Posted by Andy K
That was the cummulative of all prints owed by those deadbeats from several different exchanges over the past year and a half.
In reality it is a small number from the overall total of all participants, but it is galling to some when many are active posters.
The postcard exchange is my favourite too.
Originally Posted by mikeg
Here is my take-I assume since I have not received a PM about it I am not a dead beat. Deadbeat is the right term though.
The exchange is free and voluntary. With everything voluntary there are risks. WHat I am saying is you get what you pay for.
Since the exchange is seperate from the site and the moderators do not have any say in it then I do not feel there is anything that can be done "officially" by those folks. I don't think posting the list of deadbeats, will accomplish anything except increase the hostility that is oozing out of the floor boards as it is. Personally I do not need to know who they are.
if the organizors get together and create a blacklist, the deadbeats will not be allowed to participate in anything. If they screwed someone in one then they get screwed in all, even if they do honor some of their commitnments in other exchanges.
For example: I join two exchanges and do not honor my commitment in one but do in the other. The next time around, when I try to join the one I successfully completed I would be told by the organizor that I would not be allowed to join until I honored the other commitment.
This would take some communication, and you might ask sean if it is possible to have a secure forum for this purpose.
The other option is to make the exchanges subscriber only as this would limit the number of participants and might decrease the deadbeats. Hmmm...Unless the deadbeats are subscribers of course.
On a personal note I do not get into exchanges to receive prints. I want feed back on the images I sent. I ask for it and for the most part I get it. I am not trying to build a collection.
Now, those who whine about the quality need to be told to kiss our collective asses. We do this for fun, and to the best of our abilities. Who the F#ck are they to judge. The quality of the exchange is not dictated by who joins. it is the enthusiasm of those who participate that makes it successful. SO to the snobs out there I say o[SIZE=3]0[/SIZE]oo
Technological society has succeeded in multiplying the opportunities for pleasure, but it has great difficulty in generating joy. Pope Paul VI
So, I think the "greats" were true to their visions, once their visions no longer sucked. Ralph Barker 12/2004
I didn't think you were. I suspected you're a newbie and I wanted to clarify.
Originally Posted by ras351
It's not the process I am unhappy about, it's the fact people are not honouring their committments after they sign up. It's not like they didn't have enough time (some have had over a year now), it's not like it's onerous (most exchanges are less than 6 prints - the blind exchange with 1 - yes ONE - print to send has the largest number of deadbeats), it's not they aren't reminded (both PMs and public reminders are sent 1, 2, and 3 months after the due dates), and it's not like they are sick or have something else tragic in their lives (I know of only one person in that situation), so what is it?
It sounds like you are not happy with the process currently in place in which case you, and the other print exchange coordinators, should consider changing it.
So I ask what the poll accomplishes? The jilted recipients still don't get a print and the offenders get off scott free.
The reason I suggested the poll is because it removes the coordinator from the line of fire and allows the people who are directly effected to decide the outcome.
If they missed the original deadline by several months, what makes you think they will honour another one?
Place a reasonable deadline for this poll and any person who fails to provide prints after this time goes on 'trial'.
This isn't that complicated. This isn't like signing a mortgage or something. It's simple. It's a print exchange. Everyone knows going in that you make a few prints to send out by a due date, give or take. It's that easy. Just do it.
Detailing the commitment up front would perhaps make people use more careful consideration before they put down their name yet still give them an out under exceptional circumstances.
Sending a print allows them to reform AND honour their original committments. Once they do that they're off the list.
Having an expiry date on the blacklist allows for reform.
Thanks for the post. I still don't see how having a poll is fairer. For whom?
As mentioned they are just some thoughts which may be helpful for future exchanges. Yes, it will be more work but it may also be fairer.
LOL It's all moot anyway. Looks like people don't want to know their APUGer pal is a deadbeat in public by the looks of the other poll.
For those curious I'm not on the deadbeat list.
Sponsored Ad. (Subscribers to APUG have the option to remove this ad.)
The percentage of prints not sent vs. sent is very small. Lower than 5% and as we (I am one of the organizers) weed out those who do not mail prints this number will become lower and lower.
Let's see what I've got in the magic trash can for Mateo!
I believed that too, until I began organizing the Blind Exchange. In the last exchange close to 20% were delinquent and I hope they do honour their committments (this year).
Originally Posted by ras351
Thanks for your thoughts.
As I said, it's all moot anyway now, since it appears people want this swept under the carpet of PMs. They don't want polls. They want this dealt with behind the scenes where they won't know their APUGer pal is a deadbeat.
I am not a participate in these exchanges for a very good reason, I never know what my schdule will be or if I would be able to fullfill the committment, I do know that when I was cordinating functions of this nature, that we normally had about a 75/25 situation, in other words, 75% would do and 25% never did, it was always figured into the equation when we came up with a paticipate fueled program, based on what we did in the past, after 2 times of people saying they would and then they never did, we just did not allow them to say they would anymore, saved a lot of heartache and trouble, if you can't follow through, no reason to join, but there are those who will join anything, then life or what ever gets in the way...I think, and this is just my personal opinion, if someone says they will twice and they don't follow through, don't let them participate anylonger, and let everyone know up front that is the way it works.
As far a knowing who the offenders are, I don't care to know, different people in different circumstances do different things..
Just my .02 as a non participate..
Alternative Print Exchange!
As co-ordinator of one of the exchanges I have been urged to express an opinion although I was trying to not get too involved.
First and foremost, the term 'deadbeat' is pretty hostile - whatever the reason they failed to honour their 'contract' name calling doesn't sit well with me.
Second - it is a contract to exchange - an agreement that should be honoured and I would feel agreived if I were not to get a print after making the effort of fulling my part of the contract but not everyone has the same attitudes and standards. A list should be maintained and those failing to honour their contract by the agreed cut-of date should be notified to the exchange co-ordinator unless a private agreement has been reached by the individuals concerned!
Third - anyone who signs up for the alt exchange that is on the 'non-exchanger list' will be withdrawn from the final group make-up until such time as previous contracts are fulfilled or the matter has been settled to the mutual satisfaction of the parties involved.
Last - but not least - if subsequent alt print exchanges are highjacked by non-echangers then I shall withdraw from organising them and set up private exchanges with those who are regular contributors to the forum and with whom I am confident!
Alt Print Exchange