The analogy between vinyl and film photography, as mentioned before, is at best inaccurate. Better would be comparing looking at actual prints and listening to high-end vinyl with looking at JPEGs on a computer monitor and listening to MP3s. Litho repros of images would compare to CDs. I'd buy his argument better if he were comparing shooting film and making wet-darkroom prints to recording on 3/4" master tape on a Reel-to-Reel system vs. digital photography and printing to synthesizers and digital audio recording.