I shot TP for some years as my only b&w and my darkroom person learned how to get excellent tonality from it and found depending on developer, temperature and development time we could go for wide tonality to very high contrast and almost anything in between. I've not found a replacement film. APX25 has been okay but nothing beats TP.
I used to load the TP in several backs marked for ultimate development and switched between them depending on how I saw the final print potential.
I have 8 backs for this very reason and so I don't feel the need to just "push" a roll through in order to use a different one. So is ATP not cutting it for you? I am not sure what to make of it thus far...
"I'm the freak that shoots film. God bless the freaks!" ~ Mainecoonmaniac ~