I take your point about the inaccuracy of his description of locations. He had similar problems with dates, as he mentions in his description of Moonrise.
Originally Posted by ROL
However I'm satisfied that the photographic evidence shows that Clearing Winter Storm and the others were made within a few hundred feet either side of Tunnel View, which agrees with your original post that "New Inspiration Point is the present east end Tunnel View, where EVERYONE takes pictures – and with good reason". You were right; that's where AA took his, too. The fact that it also ties in which his recollection of the location (the road, esplenade and low stone wall) is a nice confirmation but not necessary for this conclusion.
The funny thing is, it doesn't really matter to me where they were taken. They stand by themselves; the precise location has only a slight historical interest. I mentioned "New Inspiration Point" in my review because it is such an appropriate name given the impact these photographs have had on me and so many others.
Thanks for an interesting discussion, ROL.
Last edited by andrew.roos; 05-17-2012 at 02:52 AM. Click to view previous post history.