PE are you referring to the observations in my PDF and in the thread, or the observations/clarifications Mr. Bill is quoting from the study? Sorry I'm just trying to make sure I don't get too confused here....
But I agree it seems like overanalyzing - particularly with the redacted summary version in Haist, is problematic.
I wish I had access to a microdensitometer or someone who could to RMS granularity and acutance measurements on tests. I could then carry out a similar study with current films. I have lots of ideas.
Hey maybe I could do all the developer/development/contrast work and then send it to Chris (Holmburgers) at GEH to do all the granularity and acutance testing HAHAHA