So I just finished scanning two rolls, both shot at 800 in an XA, developed at 24C in 1:50 Rodinal, one Ilford's HP5 and one Kodak's Tri-X. I was sure I was going to prefer the Tri-X but it seems to have way more grain and contrast. (I know I recently said I was looking for grain, but seriously, that was a lot)
I know the ultimate test though will be printing them and I'm planning on doing that tomorrow night.
Here's a sample of the Ilford:
Scan-130101-0035.jpg

And the Kodak
Scan-130106-0016.jpg

How do you think they compare?