[horacekenneth]

I don't think you're going to get any real answers. ...Either you dig it or you don't. And any reason is valid. That's all there is to it.

Of course we like something for a reason. You just don't like banana bread because you just dig banana bread. A 5 year old might say I just don't like Claude Monet but if you're actually studying art you should be able to discuss why you do or don't like something.
Like I said before, we don't say that some seafood is good and some seafood is bad because there are a bunch of people out there that just happen to not like seafood. There actually is a bunch of standards including freshness and preparation that distinguish good seafood from bad seafood. The red herring is the person who comes to a cooking contest and says "I just don't dig seafood."