I kinda doubt Ken actually tried either lens.
Bjørn Rørslett says that the 1.8 is better than the 2. My experience mirrors his experience, as well.
APUG: F3P, F2AS, F, FM2n
Nikkors: 24/2 AI, 43-86/3.5 AI, 55/1.2 AI, 85/1.8 K, 105/4 Micro AIS
My FB - My flickr stream