Quote Originally Posted by LJH View Post
I struggle with Rockwell's logic:

"...when shooting on 35mm, this lens is unbeaten. Even if some other 85mm lenses are a little better…"

How can something be unbeaten, even though "…other 85mm lenses are a little better…"? Surely the latter contradicts the former?

As such, I don't take his reviews too seriously.
I don't know....when you include the first part of that sentence it's meaning is more clear:

"While the newer 85mm f/1.8 AF-D and 85mm f/1.8 G are slightly better optically, they are bigger and made of plastic, and when shooting on 35mm, this lens is unbeaten. Even if some other 85mm lenses are a little better..."