The problem with rodinal is that newbies get brainwashed by other bewbies about how it's magical as a stand developer. There's so much BS conceptions flying around and when someone experienced and reasonable gives PROPER advice, he is automatically called a troll by the... Unexperienced.

Personally, I like rodinal with Hp5. The grain is just beautiful! Apx100, tmax100, fp4, plus-X...
Don't we hate digital because of the lifeless, ugly and super clean files? Give me grain!