I have gotten a number of E-mails and PMs regarding the use of Ammonia or Ammonium salts in emulsion makes.

It seems that the queries were based on a post made elsewhere which quotes T. Thorn Baker as follows:

"A small quantity of ammonia should always be present in either the salts or the first silver solutions, otherwise clots or agglomerates of precipitates may be formed, which will cause black spots on development without exposure..."

'Photographic Emulsion Technique', 1st Edition, 1941, by T. Thorne Baker. p 78.

I donít have the first edition handy, but in the second edition a similar quote is found on p 221 and rather limits this comment to paper emulsions or Cl/ClBr and Br types and goes on to give the conditions which cause pepper grain such as the wrong gelatin, too little gelatin, incorrect concentration of ingredients and etc.

In other words, Baker concedes that most emulsions donít need any Ammonia or Ammonium salts as long as the formula is a robust one. You see, experimentation is expensive and thus many early formulas were taken ďas isĒ even if they were less than optimum, and quite a few experimenters found that Ammonium ion was a quick fix for any troubles that they ran into.

With more experimentation, Baker and others found that robust formulas avoided this problem. In fact, AJ-12 and the emulsion that Mark Osterman and I used in the recent workshop are both quite robust and need no Ammonia whatsoever. And, virtually none of the hundreds of emulsion that I worked with at Kodak used Ammonia in any form.

It should be added that Ammonium ion is less effective at an acid pH, and an emulsion with Ammonium salts tends to be more acidic. Ammonia also has a strong odor if used in an alkaline environment and finally, without rigid control, Ammonia can cause severe fog. So, use of the Ammonium ion is not needed in almost every case I know of and the statement in Baker in his second edition is more realistic. Considering the above quote, Ammonia, used with the Silver Nitrate results is a more alkaline and complexing environment, while Ammonium salts in the kettle at the start of the emulsion precipitation result in a more acidic and less complexing environment. Either way, Ammonium ion was a quick fix for faulty emulsion design and is rarely used at Kodak. If a solvent is used, either other methods or solvents are used to perform the digestion. Ammonium ion in any form and at any pH, puts one on the precipice of fog!

So, this quote may have been taken out of context or Baker may have revised his thinking. Either way, it is wrong to assume that Ammonium salts of any sort are needed to preven pepper graon.