Quote Originally Posted by DLawson View Post
Speaking only for myself, please do not do so.

The criticism (as I read it) was just about context. Without that, APUG gets mired in long-standing tensions in *every* sub-forum. There is much to discuss/debate/argue in mechanics-vs-art. But that debate is not well suite to a forum on mechanics.

One of my quibbles with this (otherwise excellent) forum format is the lack of a way to note: following up in other sub-forum. The need comes up at least weekly, but the mechanism is not yet there.
I understand completely. I wasn't being facetious, I will, in fact, do my very best to adhere more strictly to the topic at hand.

But for the life of me I wouldn't know how to do so in this case, without also having a conversation on artistic intent or aesthetics or, for that matter, what is important in a photograph.

The answer to "How large can you print from a 35mm negative?" is not, to my way of thinking at least, simply a matter of math.