My $10,000 wants the original AA version, because the differences in the two processes matter to me. What matters to you... is up to you.
Of course, YMMV...
And my original issue wasn't tactility. It was provenance, in the sense of direct linkage between the subject and the medium used to record it. This provenance is asserted by the fact that the process underlying it when using film is real-world, not abstract.