That's interesting. I have the same experience with great B&W conversions from Portra. I don't do color film to B&W conversions often though. Somehow it makes me feel like I'm cheating on my B&W film.......... :-)

Quote Originally Posted by Roundabout View Post
Well I ran through a roll of Portra 400.

Very nice. The lack of grain when scanned is particularly impressive. Or, should I say, the lack of *intrusive* grain I have no problem with grain in itself.

From a colour point of view, it's hard to say. Subjectively, looking at some Kodak 200 shots I have, the Portra seems to have a bit more depth and smoothness to it. I've no intention of of doing any 'scientific' testing mind you.

Interestingly, when I did a couple of black and white converstions, the Portra gave some fantastic tones.