Most LF lenses (clean and working) will give good images and LF photogs are usually as prone to comparing MTF graphs as 35mm shooters. I would say that you could get satisfactory results with either one (I haven't tested the two you mention but this is my guess). Which one you prefer is up to you. Since you have both lenses I would recommend that you take some pictures with them both and judge for yourself which one you like the better.
Yes, I know I can shoot and compare the two. I was just asking in case there was some particular reason that one had a specific known issue that would preclude it from being a good user.