I have seen a lot of that article at our camera clubs print nights but I do think you need to put it in context. In our situation, the 'judge' (they call them something else which I can't remember) has 1-2 minutes for each print (usually 60-80 prints) so I guess you get what you pay for.. not much. However, rarely do I come away without having heard a few things to take away from what they've said (not about my pics of course! I rarely put any up anyway!) so I will continue to go and ignore the bits I don't like/agree with, or have heard 20 times already that night