I use Kokak Polycontrast III, Lustre of late, and I like it. The dull soft appearance is nice for certain subjects. I also use some Kodak Polycontrast II glossy and it's fine also.
I'm just back into a darkroom after about 5 years off, and have my own now. So like you, I just wanted to get back into it. I tried fiber a week or so ago, and I'm not saying that I won't change my mind in the future, but for they type of stuff I do, the speed and ease of RC makes me happiest!!
Does anyone know if there are any good RC papers that take to toning very easily? I've heard that most don't.