Quote Originally Posted by Tom Hoskinson
Quite right Dave!

I am impressed by logical reasoning processes that lead to well designed experiments which produce useful data.

I see no evidence of that in either of Howard Bond's pyro articles.
Well, Kirk and Sandy have been going round and round just to agree on what kind of densitometer and what values should be used when testing staining developers with a step tablet. These are two knowledgeable people and they cant seem to reach an agreement. Methinks designing a good experiment and publish it will always leave someone unhappy. Is the debate really worth it?

To add another kink to this, how about doing a test of unsharp mask vs stand development. From what I have heard those who practice SD seem to swear by it and the sharpness it produces.