Quote Originally Posted by Ed Sukach
... So, your idea and mine of "Best" are not the same. The revelation of that bit of information doesn't exactly turn my world upside down.

Obviously our ideas of a "clear winner" are not the same either.

Just don't use the word "proof". I break out into hives when I read that word.

I prefer non-solvent developers (the class into which Rodinal falls) to solvent ones (D-76, etc.) for my work. Among these, Rodinal ranks VERY low in several of the most important areas by measurement and by eye. What more remains to be said? So, I prefer developers of the Rodinal class, but Rodinal is one of the worst in its class.